Sunday, September 07, 2008 | |
 
 

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

 
Logo by
 

Welcome to our readers' forums, which we fondly call The Arena. You must be REGISTERED to post here.

 
  The Arena  News and Politi...  The Press  Whew!
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 11/19/2007 4:47 AM
  Nancy Chase
207 posts
4th Level Poster




Whew! 

I guess you said all there is to say, about Christopher Hitchens!  Ever since the Mother Teresa article, I've considered him a 'shock jock journalist extraordinaire" - he mastered the art of the short incendiary essay when he took up with Vanity Fair years ago, it became his niche.  Now he uses Slate as an even better vehicle for this kind of headline grabbing muck; its just his online version.  He is a talented writer to be sure, but when a writer uses a talent for the broader bad, has no real convictions except in seeking to villify or incense for the easy hit count reaction, it puts them right up there with the supermarket tabloid rags  The only difference being that instead of stalking celebs, he stalks world intellectuals, humanitarian, religious and political figures.

 
New Post 11/19/2007 5:31 AM
  rundeep
324 posts
3rd Level Poster


Re: Whew! 

Another well-written thing indeed. But I must confess, I read the Mother Teresa book and my husband, an avowed atheist, really enjoyed "God is not Great." On his own terms, other than the purely political sophistry in which he engages, Hitchens can be pretty persuasive. I'm not saying he's right or sober or even consistent, but I do admire his skill as a polemicist. (Actually, a few years after I read the book, I've met since some people -- former college classmates -- who claimed to have worked for or with Mother Teresa's order  who shared some of the same criticisms he had -- the nuns weren't so interested in palliative care as  with a sort of noble suffering. They stayed cause at least they were doing something, but the bit about her (and her staff) routinely undermedicating patients is something I heard.  Though whether it was due to a shortage of meds or philosophy, they weren't willing to opine.

 
New Post 11/19/2007 7:07 AM
  Nancy Chase
207 posts
4th Level Poster




Re: Whew! 

I am not an advocate of sainthood -  and it's certainly questionable if any of the saints would have been canonized in this day and age - how could anyone possibly hold up to today's scrutiny?  Mother Teresa, being merely human - in reality could never have been the idealized icon of perfect selflessness that was commonly portrayed.    She was fully human with all the foibles and predilections of humanity.    What I resented was not his questioning of her "perfectness"  but of her lifetime of devotion to the poor and suffering, which cannot be denied - as well as his insinuation of her "motives" behind her ministry.   

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  The Arena  News and Politi...  The Press  Whew!
  Maximize
Home | And Now For The News | The Arena | The Comics Page | About Quiblit
Copyright 2008 by quiblit.com | Privacy Statement | Terms Of Use